Credit: Rising Sun Films
The Indian film industry is no stranger to the gulf between critical acclaim and commercial success. Over the years, we’ve seen numerous films that, despite receiving glowing reviews from critics, fail to find a significant audience at the box office. This week, two films have added to this growing list: I Want To Talk and All We Imagine As Light.
Both films, hailed for their artistic merit and thought-provoking narratives, managed to earn a disappointing sub-Rs 1 crore at the box office over their opening weekend. To put it bluntly, this is a pitiful showing for films that were praised by critics and festivals alike. What is even more shocking is that these films couldn’t even garner more attention than a re-release of Kal Ho Naa Ho, a film that came out nearly two decades ago and is hardly an example of cinema’s ‘elite’ class.
The Flopping Of ‘I Want To Talk’ And ‘All We Imagine As Light’ Proves What?
What we’re seeing here is a harsh reality check for Indian cinema. The audience, especially the so-called “elite” who often claim to appreciate films with strong content, is simply not showing up. It’s easy to point fingers at the lack of stars or the absence of mass appeal, but the truth is more damning: these films failed because the audience doesn’t care about substance, depth, or storytelling. All they want is a quick fix, a spectacle that provides entertainment without asking too many questions. A tragedy, really, because I Want To Talk and All We Imagine As Light were made to be more than just another weekend distraction.
Also read: Box Office: Naam is a box office washout; Set to end its run with a net business of Rs 50 lakh
What stands out in the case of these films is the attitude of the very demographic that prides itself on its taste for “serious” cinema. The so-called elite and intellectually inclined audience, who endlessly debate the virtues of great art, are the ones turning a blind eye to films that challenge the norm. These are the same people who, when discussing cinema in academic or social circles, wax poetic about the need for fresh narratives, unconventional storytelling, and the importance of films that push boundaries. Yet, when it comes time to put their money where their mouth is, they fail to show up.
The Poor Weekend Collections Of Critically Acclaimed Films Are A Slap On The Face Of Intellectual Snobs
The weekend collections of both I Want To Talk and All We Imagine As Light are a slap in the face to the intellectual snobs who claim to be the guardians of meaningful cinema. These films were carefully crafted to entertain with depth, to engage with complex issues, and to elevate the discourse around Indian cinema. However, these “connoisseurs of culture” can’t seem to find time in their busy schedules to watch a movie that doesn’t come with big-budget glamour, mass appeal, or a catchy song-and-dance number. They claim to crave meaningful cinema, yet they ignore films that demand more than passive consumption.
The truth is, the Indian audience, especially the urban elite, has become obsessed with convenience. They want their films to be easy to digest, full of familiar tropes, and catered to their short attention spans. I Want To Talk and All We Imagine As Light were not made for that kind of audience. They required patience, introspection, and a willingness to engage with new ideas. That’s a luxury the average moviegoer no longer seems willing to afford.
Watch the I Want To Talk Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kZXlMsupVz8
Is The Flop Reception A Wake Up Call For The Audience
This failure at the box office isn’t just a wake-up call for the audience; it’s a blow to the very idea that Indian cinema can be more than just a vehicle for mass entertainment. When films like I Want To Talk and All We Imagine As Light struggle to earn more than Rs 1 crore in their opening weekend, it paints a grim picture of the state of cinema in India. We have reached a point where the industry seems to be catering only to the lowest common denominator, with films that prioritize spectacle and stardom over narrative and substance.
Even the re-release of Kal Ho Naa Ho is doing better at the box office, a stark reminder of the industry’s obsession with nostalgia and formulaic filmmaking. This re-release isn’t bringing anything new to the table—it’s simply playing on the audience’s nostalgia and its appetite for safe, tried-and-tested content. It’s a sad commentary on the Indian film landscape, where the new and innovative are often overshadowed by the comforting predictability of the old.
Final Thoughts On The Flopping Of ‘I Want To Talk’ And ‘All We Imagine As Light
Ultimately, the failure of I Want To Talk and All We Imagine As Light is a damning indictment of the Indian audience’s priorities. The so-called “elite” audience is more focused on their superficial idea of cinema than actually supporting films that challenge and enrich the medium. It’s time to stop pretending that we want meaningful cinema and start acting on it by showing up to theaters and rewarding films that think outside the box. Until that happens, Indian cinema will continue to be stuck in a loop of mediocrity, where only the loudest, flashiest films get attention, and the subtle, thought-provoking works are left to wither away in obscurity.
[…] Also read: Box Office: The commercial failure of ‘I Want To Talk’ and ‘All We Imagine As Light’ proves that social … […]